Rob Scuderi, number 4, the Scud Missile himself has a decision to make and so do the Pittsburgh Penguins now that the Stanley Cup is back in the ‘Burgh. Yes, the Finals are over. So too is the parade. And well, with some time to kill before Steelers start reporting for camp I have some time to think about things. Things like who among the free agents on the Pittsburgh Penguins roster should the Penguins even attempt to resign and who should they let go.

It’s life with a salary cap …

So let’s look at the list of Pittsburgh Penguins preparing to shop their services this off season:
Craig Adams, C
Mike Zigomanis, C
Mathieu Garon, G
Petr Sykora, F
Ruslan Fedotenko, F
Bill Guerin, F
Miroslav Satan, F
Hal Gill, D
Phillippe Boucher, D
Rob Scuderi, D

Now, let’s discuss …
Craig Adams – Adams was undoubtedly an upgrade on the fourth line over Godard although not much of an enforcer which you need during the regular season. Adams made $600,000 this season and could still be resigned for a reasonable price if the Penguins wanted him. He’s gritty but he’ll be a 4th liner and be a platoon guy at that in all likelihood.

Mike Zigomanis – Ziggy’s salary this year was $650,000. He’s a face off specialist and the team certainly suffered in that department after his injury. Having spent a lot of the season injured he could probably also be resigned at a reasonable rate. The problem is that the Penguins are absolutely stacked with quality role players or at least are right now. Once free agency is over this may be another story.

Mathieu Garon – Garon is a $1,000,000 backup to Fleury who wasn’t used much by the Penguins at all. The team has a glut of Goaltenders in the minors and they can let Garon go and recover some cap room. I just do not see Garon being invited back. Nothing personal.

Petr Sykora – Sykora had a price tag of $2.5 million this season. That’s pretty cheap for a scoring winger of his caliber. The problem is that his caliber has somewhat diminished it seems. He really did not perform well at all down the stretch which led to him being benched in favor of Miroslav Satan. My understanding is that Malkin likes Sykora and has a good rapport with him … but Malkin doesn’t need Sykora. Sykora will be 33 in November and while not a spring chicken he isn’t old and shriveled either. The problem is do the Penguins think that he can still score. If so, they might be able to resign him at his current value.

Ruslan Fedotenko – Now this is a guy I think the Penguins need to target for resigning. He made $2.25 million this year and complimented Malkin well. I would rather see him on Malkin’s wing than Sykora. Please, don’t take offense to that Petr, but he was definitely better and more consistent there than you were this season and if I were the Penguins I would be targeting Ruslan for a new contract. At 30 years of age he has the right mix of grit and scoring skills to be worth it. Take some of what you would pay Sykora and use it to resign Fedotenko.

Bill Guerin – Bad Boy Billy is one of those guys that I like and like a lot. Always have. Despite being 38, will be 39 in November, he looked to still have enough in him for one more year along side of Sid. $4.5 million might be a bit steep though, which is what he was making this year. I am wondering if he would take that or perhaps slightly less (considering where he is in his career) to remain a Penguin. Of course, at 38 and off of a successful Stanley Cup run maybe he is thinking of retiring. I really hope not and according to reports he has said he has no plans to retire and is looking to move his family to Pittsburgh IF the Penguins want him back.

Miroslav Satan – As much as I really enjoy all the jokes that just roll off the tongue because of having a man named Satan on the team eh, I don’t know about the Penguins interest in resigning him. He made $3.5 million this year and started out great but really had to reinvent himself as a 4th line winger. That was not what he was brought in to be and even though he played well in that roll you are not going to pay a man that kind of money to log under ten minutes of ice time a game. He’ll be 35 years of age when the season starts and he could be another guy that would just be better to let go unless he is willing to take a lot less money. Of course … he is also another candidate for retirement on a high note.

Hall Gill – Hal Gill, or more precisely Harold Priestley “Hal” Gill III, is one of those guys that you just have a hard time replacing. The man is huge and his wing span gives the opposition absolute fits while trying to enter the zone and cycling once in the zone. $2.1 million is not a bad price to pay for a shutdown defenseman like Gil and at 34 he might be coaxed to coming back at about that next year. But with a plethora of good young defensemen in the minors the Penguins may forgo him as an option on the blue line next year. I think that would be a mistake.

Phillippe Boucher – No waterboy jokes please! At $2.5 million Phillipe may be an odd man out. He came in highly touted as to what he was going to bring to the team offensively but played sparingly late in the season. You like to have defensive depth, but with the salary cap I just do not see him staying IF the Penguins target …

Rob Scuderi – Yes, I left Scuds until last for a few reasons. One of which is because I have a to say about him. Another reason is because out of all the free agents on the Penguins roster none are going to get more attention and interest than the man who night after night sacrifices life and limb and limb and limb to cause havoc in the defensive zone. Scuderi made a paltry $725,000 this season and is worth more; a lot more. I do not know that you can replace him for his current salary so if the price is right the Penguins have to try and bring him back. The kind of kamikaze style he plays just cannot be taught. It is instinctive. It takes a certain kind of … well … nut to play it. I mean that in the nicest possible way Scuds. And it is very hard to convince a guy to get into the path of pucks like he does for that price.

I say the Penguins have to make an attempt to sign him. Not for ungodly sums of money mind you, but something serious and in line with other defensemen on the team. I do not think that $2,000,000 would be unreasonable, but more than that just might be. That being said, if some team throws a bucket full of dollars at Scuds I would not begrudge him leaving for financial security. He’s 30 but you could sign him for 2 or 3 years I think and have a good investment.

Now, let the games begin!